SEO + GEO · 16 Nov 2026 · 10 MIN READ

How to Choose an SEO Agency in Australia: What to Ask

Choosing an SEO agency in Australia comes down to proof, a plain report on enquiries and your own access. Agencies average $3,209 a month (Ahrefs).

Joshua Schubert Joshua Schubert

Choosing an SEO agency in Australia comes down to four checks you can make before signing: proof of results for businesses like yours, a monthly report built on enquiries rather than rankings, a contract you can leave, and your website, Google Business Profile and Search Console staying in your own name. An agency that passes all four is worth talking to. One that promises a guaranteed first place in Google is not, and Google says so itself.

I’m writing this as someone who sells SEO, so read it with that in mind. The questions below are the ones I would want a client to ask me, and the ones I ask myself before I take a job: what will change for this business, how will we both know, and what happens if it doesn’t work.

We sell this as Compound SEO & GEO: one plan at $1,500 a month plus GST, covering SEO and the AI search side together, with a three-month minimum and then 30 days notice either way. Use the checks below on us as hard as on anyone else.

What should an SEO agency actually do for a service business?

An SEO agency for a service business does the work that gets the business found by people looking for its services: technical fixes so Google can crawl and index the site, a page for each service and area, titles that earn the click, the Google Business Profile, reviews and consistent business details across directories. The agency should then report what that work brought in.

Google Search Central lists the same kind of work on its page about hiring an SEO: a review of site content or structure, technical advice on hosting, redirects and error pages, content development, keyword research and expertise in specific markets and geographies. The list now also includes optimising for generative AI, which is the part of search where ChatGPT and Google’s AI answers name a business directly (Google Search Central).

So the first question is simple: what exactly will you do in the first three months, and in what order? A good answer names pages, fixes and the profile. A vague answer about “boosting authority” tells you very little.

What questions should you ask an SEO agency before you sign?

The questions to ask an SEO agency before signing are about proof, method, measurement and ownership, because those four decide whether you can judge the work later. Google’s own guide suggests asking for examples of previous work, whether the agency follows Google Search Essentials, what results to expect in what timeframe, and how it measures success.

Question to askA good answer sounds likeA warning sign
Can you show work for a business like mine?Named examples, with what changed in enquiriesOnly screenshots of rankings
What will you do in the first 90 days?Specific pages, fixes and profile work, in order”We’ll boost your authority”
How will you report?Calls, forms and bookings from search, plus rankings for the searches that bring workTraffic and rankings only
Who owns the site, content and profile?You do, and it stays with you when you leaveThe agency holds the logins
What is the minimum term?A short minimum, then monthly noticeA long lock-in with exit fees
Can you guarantee first place?NoYes

The pattern across the table is that a good agency answers in terms of your business and your access, while the warning signs are all about rankings you cannot check and control you cannot take back.

That last row matters most to me. Google Search Central puts it in one line:

“No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google.”

Google Search Central, Do you need an SEO? (Google Search Central)

The same page warns against SEOs who claim a “special relationship” with Google or a “priority submit”, and says a company that is secretive about what it intends to do is a reason to be careful.

What should an SEO agency cost in Australia?

SEO agency pricing in Australia is mostly a monthly retainer, and the best published benchmark is global. Ahrefs polled 439 SEO service providers and found that 78.2% of SEOs charge a monthly retainer, that SEO costs usually range from $250 to $10,000 per month, and that agencies charge $3,209 per month on average while freelancers charge $1,348 (Ahrefs).

Treat those numbers as a range, not an Australian price list, because the survey covers providers worldwide. What they do tell you is that a fee well under the freelancer average buys very few hours a month, and that a fee well over the agency average should come with a scope you can read line by line.

Our plan sits under the agency average at $1,500 a month plus GST, one plan with no tiers. It covers technical SEO, titles and descriptions, service and suburb pages, usually two new articles or pages a month plus refreshes, internal links and structured data, the Google Business Profile, directory details, a monthly check of what the AI assistants say and a monthly report. It does not include ads. If you want to test whether any SEO fee pays for itself, our post on whether local SEO is worth it works it out from your profit per customer.

How should an SEO agency report results?

SEO agency reporting should start with what you care about, which is calls, form enquiries and bookings that came from search, and only then show rankings and traffic as the reasons behind them. Google Search Central suggests asking an SEO directly how they measure success, and the answer should name numbers you can check yourself in Google Analytics and Search Console.

I’d ask to see a sample report before signing. A useful one says what was done that month, which pages are indexed, how the searches that bring work are ranking, what the AI assistants said about the business, and what comes next. If every chart goes up and nobody can tell you how many enquiries came in, the report is measuring the agency’s activity, not your result.

Give it time, too. Most of this work takes three to six months before there is much to look at, so a six-week verdict either way tells you little. The same measurement logic applies to AI search, and our guide on choosing a GEO agency covers what a report on AI answers should contain.

Who should own your website, profile and data?

Your business should own every account the SEO work touches: the website, the domain, the Google Business Profile, Search Console and Google Analytics. The agency gets access as a user you can remove. Google Business Profile is built for exactly this, because the owner keeps full control and can add or remove managers at any time.

Google’s help page sets out the structure plainly:

“A Business Profile can have multiple owners but only one primary owner.”

Google Business Profile Help, Manage your Business Profile owners & managers

Make sure the primary owner is you. On Search Console, Google’s hiring guide is specific about the early stage: if an SEO offers to do an audit, “only grant read access to Search Console (at this stage, don’t grant them write access)” (Google Search Central).

The same goes for the work itself. Everything we publish stays on the client’s site and stays theirs if they leave, and I think that should be the standard you hold any agency to.

What are the red flags when hiring an SEO agency?

SEO agency red flags are guarantees of first place, unexplained techniques, link schemes and lock-in contracts, and Google Search Central names most of them on its hiring page. The page also warns about agencies that email you out of the blue, and reminds owners that they are responsible for the actions of any company they hire.

The red flags I would act on:

  • A guaranteed ranking, a “special relationship” with Google or a “priority submit”.
  • An agency that will not explain what it is changing on your site.
  • Talk of link schemes or of submitting your site to thousands of search engines.
  • Logins, the profile or the domain held in the agency’s name.
  • A long minimum term with an exit fee and no monthly report to judge it by.

Google’s page also says that if an SEO creates deceptive or misleading content on your behalf, your site could be removed from Google’s index entirely. That risk is yours, not the agency’s, which is why I’d rather lose a sale than use a shortcut on a client’s site. For complaints, Google’s page points US businesses to the Federal Trade Commission and everyone else to econsumer.gov. The cheaper protection for an Australian business is keeping its accounts in its own name from day one.

How do you start with an SEO agency without a big commitment?

Starting with an SEO agency is easiest with a short, written first step: an audit of the site and the Google Business Profile against the searches that bring you work, and a plan for the first three months. You should come out of that step knowing what will change and how you will measure it, whether or not you sign.

That is how we start. Send us your website and the services you most want enquiries for and we will tell you where the business stands and what the first three months of our SEO and GEO plan would do, at $1,500 a month plus GST. You can also see how the plan is priced against our other services. For businesses up here, it is the same work we do for SEO clients in Cairns and around Australia.

Frequently asked questions

How do I choose an SEO agency in Australia?

Choose an SEO agency in Australia by checking four things: proof of results for similar businesses, a monthly report built on calls and enquiries from search, a contract with a short minimum term, and your website, Google Business Profile and Search Console staying in your own name. Avoid any agency that guarantees first place in Google.

Can an SEO agency guarantee a first-page ranking?

No agency can guarantee a first-place ranking. Google Search Central states that “No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google” and warns against SEOs who claim a special relationship with Google. A trustworthy agency promises the work and the reporting, not a position.

How much does an SEO agency cost per month?

An SEO agency usually charges a monthly retainer. Ahrefs’ global survey of 439 SEO providers found agencies charge $3,209 per month on average and freelancers $1,348. Compound SEO & GEO costs $1,500 a month plus GST, one plan covering SEO and AI search, with a three-month minimum.

How long before SEO shows results?

We tell clients to expect three to six months before there is much to measure, because pages have to be crawled, indexed and ranked before they bring enquiries. Judge an agency on whether the work it reports each month matches the plan it agreed with you, then on enquiries once the work has had time.

Read more

Let's compound

Tell us where growth stalls.

One team that connects your website, marketing and operations, so the results compound. Pick whichever way is easiest to start.

Australian-based · Founder on every project